reproduced certificate script asserted: CERTIFIED chi(qubit_T^4) >= 3
Pairs with the rank-3 upper bound to settle this cell at χ = 3 exactly. Closes it as a route to the published exponent log_2(3)/4, which would need rank 2 here. The stabilizer states are enumerated by closing the Clifford orbit of |0...0> rather than from a phase parametrisation, since the verifier's witness format uses w2 = -1 and so reaches only the real stabilizer states, missing the Y eigenstates; the count is checked against 2^n prod (2^k + 1). The exclusion rests on a margin rather than exact arithmetic: the closest any two candidate directions come to parallel is 0.76 to 0.78 against a threshold of 1 - 1e-6, so no rounding at the 1e-15 level of these inputs can close the gap. The H-type state at m=2 has a known rank-2 decomposition, which the same code finds as a positive control.
this repository · stabrank PR #18 · exhaustion over all pairs of stabilizer states, via the quotient by the target
{
"schema_version": "0.1",
"orbit": "qubit_T",
"m": 4,
"direction": "lower",
"rank": 3,
"certificate": {
"script": "verify_challenge/cert_qubit_rank2.py",
"expect": "CERTIFIED chi(qubit_T^4) >= 3"
},
"provenance": {
"author": "this repository",
"reference": "stabrank PR #18",
"method": "exhaustion over all pairs of stabilizer states, via the quotient by the target",
"date": "2026-09-12",
"github": [
"vprusso"
]
},
"notes": "Pairs with the rank-3 upper bound to settle this cell at chi = 3 exactly. Closes it as a route to the published exponent log_2(3)/4, which would need rank 2 here. The stabilizer states are enumerated by closing the Clifford orbit of |0...0> rather than from a phase parametrisation, since the verifier's witness format uses w_2 = -1 and so reaches only the real stabilizer states, missing the Y eigenstates; the count is checked against 2^n prod (2^k + 1). The exclusion rests on a margin rather than exact arithmetic: the closest any two candidate directions come to parallel is 0.76 to 0.78 against a threshold of 1 - 1e-6, so no rounding at the 1e-15 level of these inputs can close the gap. The H-type state at m=2 has a known rank-2 decomposition, which the same code finds as a positive control."
}